Subalterns
and Sovereigns: An Anthropological history of Bastar
1854-2006, Delhi, Oxford University Press, 2007 (2nd edition), (1st
edition 1997, OIP 1999).
Anthropologists are often accused of wanting to keep
tribals or indigenous people as museum pieces. Subalterns
and Sovereigns shows how misplaced this charge is, arguing that forested
and hill areas like Bastar have never been outside
the ‘mainstream’ of history, and that the flattening out of local politics to
create the appearance of isolation and homogeneity is essentially a product of
colonialism and post-colonialism. The choice today, as in the past, has never
been one between ‘tradition’ and ‘modern civilisation’ or between ‘development’
and ‘backwardness’, but over alternative visions of democracy.
By exploring the expansion of the state in Bastar
over the past century and a half, and resistance to the particular forms it has
taken, this book has been part of redefining the way in which history and
anthropology are thinking of tribal India.
Based on an
unusually rich combination of field and archival research, deployed in
methodologically innovative ways, the book is divided into three parts: the ethnohistorical first section portrays the pre-colonial
economy and polity, showing also how the significance of kingship and Bastar’s famous Dussehra festival
have changed over time. The second part uses more standard archival sources to
explore critical rebellions, yet these too are countered by oral histories of
the same events. This section documents the growing restrictions on popular
access to land and forest, the multiple historical understandings that shaped
the encounter between different actors, and the relationship between colonial
anthropology and contemporary laws. The final section, `Uncertain Futures,'
highlights the contradictions faced by tribal societies today. The book is
brought up to date for the second edition, by an afterword
on the ongoing Naxalite movement and the government’s
counterinsurgency efforts in Chhattisgarh.